Skip to main content

Best Heart Beat

As a holistic cardiologist, I am often questioned about the antioxidant trials… HOPE, HPS, the Physicians’ Health Study. Thousands of patients studied, no benefits. So are antioxidants a waste?

Well, there are a lot of issues with the trials but two in particular merit attention. 1. They tested isolated (usually synthetic) compounds. 2. Even if we redesigned the studies with the correct supplements (whole food based supplements like Kickstart my Heart, Wild Salmon Roe, or shilajit), they still wouldn’t be addressing the ROOT CAUSE.

They used one isolated molecule

They always used one isolated molecule. Vitamin E in nature is 8 compounds. The trials gave only alpha tocopherol. There are hundreds of carotenoids, the trials used one. This matters because when you take 400 IU of alpha tocopherol a day, your gamma tocopherol drops by about half in two months. Your body stops absorbing the related compounds. Take beta carotene alone and the same thing happens. You stop absorbing the other carotenoids. None of the cofactors were included in the trials.

Whole foods deliver the cofactors

Liver or a freeze dried salmon egg delivers the antioxidant along with the selenium, the zinc, the sulfur amino acids and the fats they travel with. A pharma produced capsule delivers it naked. My favorite example is a 1951 rat study. Rats fed synthetic B vitamins swam 13 minutes in cold water. Rats fed whole liver extract swam 2 hours (9 out of 12 were still swimming at the 2 hour mark). The right supplement increased endurance roughly ten times.

Sometimes megadosed isolated vitamins do harm

In one trial, statin plus niacin raised HDL2 by 42 percent… add isolated antioxidants (beta carotene, E, C, selenium) and the HDL2 rise disappeared, along with the benefit on the angiogram. Isolated beta carotene INCREASED lung cancer 18 percent in smokers. Vitamin E INCREASED prostate cancer 17 percent in another large trial.

So what do these trials tell us?

Isolated, usually synthetic, antioxidants don’t work and sometimes cause harm. Oxidation and inflammation cause virtually all chronic disease. Antioxidants in their natural state, along with cofactors, help with this.

However, the question remains… WHAT was oxidizing the arteries in the first place. That investigation is crucial and is probably more important than which supplement to take.

I never recommend isolated, synthetic antioxidants. I recommend the foods they came from, and whole food supplements like Wild Salmon Roe, Kickstart my Heart (or other freeze dried organ alternatives) and shilajit resin, where your body sorts out the ratios and absorbs the nutrients and cofactors in natural forms.

Do you still take an isolated antioxidant? Which one, and why?

Related reading


Andrew Rudin, MD is a cardiologist and board-certified cardiac electrophysiologist who takes a natural, root-cause approach to heart health. He sees telehealth patients nationally and internationally through Natural Heart Doctor, and is licensed in Tennessee. He has been quoted as an expert source by Medscape and Men’s Journal, and was profiled in The Village Voice. More at andrewrudinmd.com.

This article is for general education and is not medical advice. It is not a substitute for care from your own physician, and nothing here should be used to start, stop, or change treatment on your own.

Second opinion · Telehealth

Book a Consult with Dr. Rudin

A root-cause review of your heart health — your labs, your medications, and any procedure you’ve been told you need — so you can decide with the full picture.

Book a Consult →

Consults are provided through Natural Heart Doctor. Educational, not medical advice.